Jagdpanther vs SU Eastern Front Duel Author: David R. Higgins; Illustrator: Richard Chasemore; Short code: DUE Jagdpanther vs SU Author: David R. Higgins ISBN: 1 6. Contributor: Andrew Nguyen Review Date: 17 Sep As with all German. However, from page 33 until the end of the book, we leave the discussion specifically of the Jagdpanther and SU, and launch into a military.
|Published (Last):||15 April 2004|
|PDF File Size:||11.33 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||15.36 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
I hate being bi-polar. SU Russian SU at a tank biathlon.
Jagdpanther vs SU-100: Eastern Front 1945
It is not limited to icing, but other debris can cause issues between the overlapping wheels. Both German and Soviet military theorists in the years leading up to WW2 incorporated tanks into their battle plans to exploit breakthroughs in the enemy’s lines. Exported SUs continued in service until the s, and in some countries, even later. Andrew marked it as to-read Nov 23, iagdpanther Also, pure performance, not reliability. Oct 13, Christopher rated it really liked it Shelves: Posted December 29, edited.
SU-100 vs Jagdpanther
The SU has been proven to operate in extreme cold and extreme heat, and in difficult environments such as the Middle Eastern jagdpanthee as the SUM. Major Fulcrum 12 Posted 20 November – As minor jagdpantber it may seem, I feel that the DS’s shorter gun barrel will get the SU into less trouble than the PaK 43’s barrel will get the Jagdpanther. Certainly not twice as strong as Soviet steel of the same thickness.
Don’t be afraid of the Jagdpanther though, I thought it was pretty good, and it was one of the only 2 tier 7 TD’s I kept after grinding through it. Ease of production, assuming equal resources and similar manufacturing ability, would be the SU due to the smaller dimensions and less complicated design. One thing people seem to miss out on the SU was its main flaw: Matthew J35U5 13 Posted 20 November – Julio Campos added it Jun 09, The SU and Jagdpanther seem quite similar vehicles: They’re both very similar firepower, mobility and armor wise the Jagdpanther has a gun with a bit more penetration and comes with APCR while reloading faster too but the Su’s gun deals more damage in case of penetrations the Su accelerates faster and has a slightly higher top speed but its gun takes more time to stabilize during short stops the Jagdpanther has a big more armour to the front but it has a much jagdpantehr silhouette and is easier to hit, but also has better gun depression.
Posted December 29, They carried out the same test:. From vw I have read, the mobility of both vehicles appears to be excellent.
Purely on performance, I think I’d still go for a Su Jeff rated it liked it Dec 18, Development was conducted under supervision of L. Lists with This Book. Such vehicles were cheaper to manufacture than tanks. The various ammunition used for the Pak 43 guns was around 10kg or 11kg, where as the DS used ammunition in the 16kg range. The vz design is problematic, as is the other Panther elements of the Jagdpanther.
And while there were undoubtedly Jagdpanther and SU units involved in all this fighting, the book wanders far and wide in its battlefield coverage, with little directly about specific Jagdpanther and SU unit actions. It’s very close but I think the JPanther was best as it was an all round better performing jagdpanher, it’s only weakness compared to the Su is being bigger and more costly to make.
To ask other readers questions about Jagdpanther vs SUplease sign up.
Duel 1 – 10 of 86 books. Matthew J35U5 jagdpanthsr Posted 04 November – This is of course not surprising, as tank destroyers are meant as ambush and defensive vehicles, and aren’t meant to trade shots with other vehicles.
SU Vs. Jagdpanther – Historical Discussion – War Thunder – Official Forum
Both are very similar. This battlefield history is all very interesting, and for the most part fairly well written, but it certainly wasn’t what I was expecting to dominate in a book titled “Jagdpanther vs SU”.
Matthew J35U5 1 Posted 03 November – If you have nothing in your library on the Jagdpanther or SU, and also happen to be interested in the Eastern Front situation in as it pertains to the battles for Hungary, then this book could jadpanther of interest to you.
Community Forum Software by IP. Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Wikimedia Commons has media related to SU Before the war, the Soviet Union was sent a Pz. Retrieved 4 October Cs also dislike the German use of interleaved suspension.
Both vehicles can carry a fair amount of fuel internally, though the Jagdpanther can carry the most but not enough to compensate for range performance of the Jagdpamther So I’d pick the JP. K Lennart marked it as to-read Mar 06, Myers is currently reading it Dec 25,